Wipe off any scuffs on the soccer shoes with a dry, clean white cloth immediately following the game or practice session. Some turf marks will be light or superficial and will easily come off right away. Store the cleats in a mesh bag for the ride home; the mesh allows airflow, which helps the shoes air out and breathe during transport.
Clean the darker or more severe marks on the cleats as soon as you return home. Delaying the cleaning process can cause the dirt and turf to set into the leather, making it more difficult to remove the marks.
Stroke a pencil eraser or artist's eraser gently over the rubber turf marks. This method works best with light or superficial marks. Rub the marks softly to avoid removing a layer of material on the shoes. If that doesn't work, move on to the next step.
Dampen a clean cloth with warm water. Rub the wet rag over the scuffs on the soccer shoes until the marks are gone. If the marks are still visible, grab a toothbrush.
Scrub the marks with a toothbrush and a small amount of non-gel toothpaste to clean the shoes. Rub the spot gently using a circular motion until the marks are gone. Wipe the toothpaste off of the shoes with a clean, wet cloth.
Cover the marks with shoe polish or refinishing spray if no other methods have removed the scuffs from the shoes. Stuff the shoes with newspaper to keep the insides dry. Apply the polish or spray as directed by the manufacturer. Use thin coats of polish or spray for an even finish. Allow the shoes to dry between coats.